Jacob B. Rath 1860-1865 (Moved to a parish in Bethlehem, PA)
Reuben S. Wagner 1867-1869 (Moved to a parish in Hinkletown, PA)
David Kuntz 1869-1901 (Moved to a parish in Forks, PA)
Luther D. Lazarus 1902-1905 (Moved to a parish in Bethlehem, PA)
George D. Druckenmiller 1905-1910 (Moved to a parish in Hamburg, PA)
John H. Miller 1910-1913 (Moved to a parish in Missouri)
Milton M. Dry 1913-1925 (Passed away in his sleep on September 25, 1925)
Harvey C. Snyder 1926-1956 (Became ill during a Sunday service and passed away on Wednesday afternoon)
Alfred L. Long 1956-1982 (Retired and was named Pastor Emeritus of St. John’s)
Paul H. Spohn 1983-1989 (Named Coordinator of the Northeastern Pennsylvania Synod of the ELCA)
David B. Schaeffer 1989-2017 (Retired)
Scott A. Hall 2019 - Present, Jennifer L. Hall 2022 - Present